Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, 203 Brown, 0.01 oz | Waterproof pencil eyeliner with built-in sharpener. Smudge-proof, long-lasting, intense matte color.

Overall Sentiment: Our feedback is mixed. We like the eyeliner’s appearance and ease of application, but inconsistent smudge resistance and product-quality issues make it difficult to recommend without reservations.

What We Like: We appreciate the beautiful look, smooth application, and reports that the eyeliner lasts all day without smudging. When it works as intended, it is easy to use and provides lasting wear.

What We Dislike: Performance is inconsistent: some of us say it stays put, while others find that it smudges across the eyes. We are also concerned that the tip frequently breaks and that the product can be too dry to apply effectively.

Common Themes: Reviews repeatedly mention the eyeliner’s attractive result, smooth and simple application, and potential for all-day wear. Smudge resistance is a recurring point of disagreement, while dryness and a break-prone tip are notable reliability concerns.

Our Recommendation: We would recommend it only cautiously. It may suit us if we value its look and easy application, but the inconsistent wear and reports of dryness and breakage suggest that the experience may vary. We would want more reliable performance before giving it an unqualified recommendation.